1. Bolivarians
Some Latin-American leaders have a habit of criticizing Spain for its invasions centuries ago.
Maybe inspired by that, some Latin-American friends teased me in grad school:
ME: Where are you from?
LATAM FRIEND: I’m from [Former Spanish colony], and you?
ME: Spain and France.
LAF: Ah! Spanish! Aren’t you ashamed to be the heir of genocidal conquistadors?
ME: I mean, I was born and raised in Europe. My ancestors probably stayed in Europe. They were not the ones doing the conquering. But I do wonder if you’ve looked at yourself in the mirror. You seem pretty white to me.”
It reflects the ethnic makeup of the Latin-American leadership.

Some Spaniards did conquer most of America with guns, germs, and steel, driven by greed, causing unbelievable pain and death. The scale of the tragedy is unfathomable.
But it’s not like Hernán Cortés and his handful of Spaniards disturbed a stable, prosperous, and harmonious Aztec civilization. The Mexica ruled the Aztec Empire from their capital, Tenochtitlan, and they were inconvenient enough to the surrounding tribes that these tribes preferred to partner with the Spaniards to take down the Mexica.
That was just the state of affairs when Spaniards arrived. Before the Aztecs, there had been layers upon layers of civilizations replacing each other: Olmec, Zapotec, Mixtec, Huastec, Toltec…
The Aztecs might have been the most recent, but recency didn’t come with modernity.

2. Columbus
In the US, there’s a heavy debate on whether we should celebrate Columbus Day to commemorate Christopher Columbus’s discovery of America. The opponents of that day reasonably prefer Indigenous Day, as it celebrates the Native Americans who lost everything following the European conquests.
We’ve mentioned the carnage Spaniards caused in Mexico, but an even better example is what happened to the Taíno, a group of indigneous people inhabiting some Caribbean islands when Columbus arrived, and whom he described as kind and generous. They had come a few centuries earlier, probably from South America. But a few decades after Columbus's arrival, only a few hundred remained—like the Aztecs, most Taínos were killed by diseases, the rest through oppression. Today, the Taíno people and culture are virtually extinct. A genocide.
But the history of the Taíno isn’t as simple as happy, local indigenous people who were then massacred by the conquistadors. In fact, it appears the Spanish arrived just as another tribe, the Carib, were driving Taínos out of the Caribbean islands. The Carib had nice habits like cannibalism.
The Taíno and Carib invasions were just two of many waves of invasions, each of which replaced the previous inhabitants. Layers of genocide. The Spaniards were just the most recent and efficient.

3. Slavers
Walk the majestic streets of cities like London, Liverpool, Lisbon, Bordeaux, or Nantes, and you will come across opulent castles, monuments, museums, or administration buildings—the pompous wealth of a decadent past.

When I see those monumental buildings, however, I imagine an old parchment with two columns. The first one portrays the costs of the buildings: the masons, the architects, the marble, the mirrors. The second column displays the number of slaves sold to finance them.
For centuries, Europe was the main beneficiary of the triangular Atlantic trade: Slaves were transported to America, where they were exchanged for raw materials like sugar, tobacco, and cotton, which would be traded in Europe for finished goods sold in Africa.
The wealth accumulated benefited the European countries in general, and the main slaver cities in particular. Portugal, France, and the UK benefited the most1.
Wouldn’t it have been easier to simply conquer Africa and use local slaves instead of transporting them for months? No, Europeans could not conquer Africa back then. But then how did Europeans capture slaves in Africa if they couldn’t conquer the continent?
They bought them from Africans. Local kingdoms and warring tribes raided each other and captured slaves for the trade.
This slave trade with Europeans was not the only one in Africa.
The African continent was bled of its human resources via all possible routes. Across the Sahara, through the Red Sea, from the Indian Ocean ports and across the Atlantic. At least ten centuries of slavery for the benefit of the Muslim countries (from the ninth to the nineteenth) ... Four million enslaved people exported via the Red Sea, another four million through the Swahili ports of the Indian Ocean, perhaps as many as nine million along the trans-Saharan caravan route, and eleven to twenty million (depending on the author) across the Atlantic Ocean.—Elikia M'bokolo, Le Monde Diplomatique.
Each of these dramatic extractions of humans was a tragedy. Not only that: to this day, Africa is the only continent where rugged areas are more developed than flat ones. The main reason? Rugged areas probably couldn’t suffer from as much slave trade.
Europeans, Asians, Americans, and Africans. All participated in this despicable act, for their own profit. To those who believe in racial brotherhood, Africans enslaving other Africans might be even more repulsive. In terms of numbers, Europeans were the worst offenders simply because they had the most power.
There were lots of assholes everywhere.
4. Hans and Franks
In What China Wants and Why, I explain why 95% of the inhabitants of the most populous country in the world belong to the same ethnicity. The Hans were blessed with the best geography in the entire region, and used that to integrate or eliminate all competing ethnicities. Systematic genocide, cultural and ethnic. We can see it in action today with Xinjiang’s Uyghurs.
Other countries aren’t much better. In How to Understand France, I show how France’s geography gave those controlling the region around Paris enough power to extend their control from the North Sea to the Mediterranean. The side-effect is that all regional differences have been stomped, subject to the systematic centralization of Paris. Most people living across French regions feel French—the “descendants of the Franks”—even if many probably don’t have much Frankish blood, especially in the south. The power has been used for centuries to assimilate peoples and annihilate differences in the name of the nation.
Although France has been at it for more centuries than any other European nation-state, the others have used similar cultural engineering tactics to systematically integrate disparate regions. And they’ve done it at all levels: in regions like Wallonia and Flanders, countries like Germany and Italy, or continents like the European Union. Every government is just trying to control people and memes for its own benefit. In the process, thousands of years of diversity have been forgotten.
5. The Levant
No land in history has suffered more layers of control and genocide than the Levant: Assyrians, Akkadians, Hittites, Babylonians, Egyptians, Macedonians, Ptolemaics, Seleucids, Hebrews, Romans, Byzantines, Arabs, Crusaders, Mamluks, Ottomans, British, Palestinians, Zionists… This video makes a compelling case.
All countries search historical facts that suit their narratives to feed their thirst for control and power. But the Levant makes that history-twisting more ridiculous than any other country: with so many layers of death and control, you can argue anything you want and nothing at the same time. The only thing that’s consistent in history about that piece of land is the systematic killing of layers after layers of conquerors.
This has been the story of humans. We’ve killed each other for control. Those successful eliminated their enemies and kept their riches. We are all the children of genocides.
The more we looked different, the more aggressive we were. It makes sense, then, that others who looked even more different would be fully exterminated.
6. Neanderthals
Neanderthals could create fire, produce adhesive tar, craft simple clothes, weave, go seafaring through the Mediterranean, treat severe injuries, store food, cook, engrave, produce music, communicate through language…
And then about 40k years ago, just as we Homo Sapiens arrived where Neaderthals lived, they disappeared, leaving nothing but a few remains in the soil and in our genes through interbreeding.
We learn about it in school like it isn’t a big deal. We won, they lost, suckers. But have you stopped to think about how much of a catastrophe of epic proportions this is? There were other humans! Like us! They could likely talk! But we made them go extinct. We killed them all! That’s true genocide.
Imagine if some race of aliens appeared here and thought: How cute are these locals. Let’s kill them all. Thousands of years later, they would teach in school how there was another species before them here, but then the good aliens came in and prevailed. How would we feel about complete extinction?
If only Neanderthals were the only ones… It looks like most homos disappeared in similar circumstances, like the Denisovans.
The dust of species’ history is bathed in blood.
7. Megafauna
Why were dinosaurs much bigger than animals today?
Turns out they weren’t: the blue whale is bigger than any dinosaur was.

OK fine. Why were dinosaurs bigger than the land animals that came after them?
Turns out they weren’t either.
The T-Rex and triceratops weighed about 6 and 10 tons respectively. They were 4m and 3m high. Compare that to the Palaeoloxodon Namadicus, a type of elephant that lived at the same time as humans, weighed 22 tons, and was over 5m high. They were substantially bigger than these famous dinosaurs.
Dozens of huge animals lived after dinosaurs, and many of them coexisted with humans. Then suddenly, as humans spread, these animals started disappearing. The most likely explanation is that humans killed them.
It also makes sense: if you’re a hungry human, will you hunt the small and nimble animals, or the huge and slow ones?
Animals that coevolved with humans learned to fear them. That’s why all the land megafauna remaining in the world is in Africa: elephants, giraffes, hippos2… They stayed away from humans. But megafauna outside of Africa didn’t evolve a fear of humans. And the bigger these animals were, the fewer predators they had to fear, so truly huge animals simply had no threats.
Now imagine you’re human, and huge, dumb animals are easy prey because they don’t run away from you. What will you do? Hunt them and hunt them and hunt them, so fast and so systematically, that within a few generations they disappeared.
This also explains why the megafauna of today are smaller than the megafauna of yesteryear: we’ve been systematically killing the biggest specimens. Those remaining are the smaller ones.
Dinosaurs were not especially big. They just didn’t have a single species that systematically applied “natural” selection against the bigger specimens. Our layers of genocide don’t stop at other cultures, or even other homos. We’ve been driving extinct species after species, even before we started recording history.
All of this also explains why the biggest animals still alive are in the sea, not on land: we’ve only been exterminating sea animals for a few centuries, with our navigational developments. Since then, we’ve just started learning that we shouldn’t be assholes all the time.
8. 2222
GAËLLE: Dad, Octavius is very sick, isn’t it?
DAD: Yes
GAËLLE: Are we going to take him to the doctor?
DAD: We’re going to put him down.
GAËLLE: No way! That’s horrible!
DAD: You know, in the past, they used to eat octopuses.
GAËLLE: What?! How could they?! Didn’t they know they are sentient and intelligent?
DAD: They learned it in the 21st century. They still ate them.
GAËLLE: That’s crazy! They were monsters!
DAD: Wait until you hear what they did to fellow humans.
GAËLLE: Nooooooo! What?
DAD: They laughed and discriminated against the neurodiverse.
GAËLLE: Impossible. So what happened if you had autism, or a severe disability?
DAD: It depends. People would laugh at them, think they’re weird, avoid them. Many were marginalized and ended up dying early.
GAËLLE: I can’t believe it.
DAD: But you didn’t even need to be neurodiverse to be discriminated against. It was enough to be born in the wrong place.
GAËLLE: Wait what? What do you mean?
DAD: You know countries, right? They used to be somewhat different. Much more powerful. Back then, they behaved a bit like clubs. Most people could only belong to one if they were born into it. If they were born in the wrong club, they only had rights to whatever that club could afford. In some countries in Africa, for example, millions would routinely die because of easily-treatable infections, or simply for a lack of food.
GAËLLE: So people would live or die just because of where they were born? They were barbaric in the 21st century!
DAD: They called those in the club “compatriots” or “citizens”, and the others “foreigners” or “immigrants”. If you were a citizen, you had plenty of rights. Foreigners had nothing. I remember it well.
GAËLLE: You guys were assholes.
Takeaways
Animals are assholes. They kill without a second thought. If they drive other species extinct, so be it.
Humans, like other animals, have done the same for most of their history.
It didn’t matter whether they exterminated animals or humans.
They’ve done it generation after generation, tribe after tribe, chiefdom after chiefdom, empire after empire, religion after religion, country after country. Assholes all the way down.
Only very recently have we started caring about others. As time passes, we do it more and more. But we’re still in the process, and things that appear completely normal to us will appear abhorrent to us in the future.
This has plenty of consequences about how we think today.
The Past Is Another Country
Nation-states insert propaganda into kids’ education to make them think there’s continuity in the nations, but the truth is that people from other times were other people. We owe them nothing. They owe us nothing. You’re closer to foreigners today than to compatriots from another time.
For example, we Americans have been taught that we rebelled against the British and our founding fathers founded our country. But for starters those who rebelled were British (colonists) against British. And the founding fathers were just a bunch of highly intelligent political scientists that got it quite right when designing their constitution. But they didn’t get it perfectly by any means. Enshrining them into some sort of god-like ancestors confuses us and prevents us from seeing the truth: the American constitution has plenty of bugs, and if modern Americans saw that, we would correct it more diligently.
Pick Your Own History
You can make any argument you want with history. So many things have happened that there’s always something politicians can latch onto to make their case, always an injustice to make people’s blood boil, always a detail to legitimize their designs.
So take any historical argument with a grain of salt: Somebody is trying to twist facts to get something from you.
What Matters Is Today
Are you your ancestors? Are you responsible for their deeds? No.
Should you compensate others for your ancestors’ behavior? No.
Should some give reparations to others? I don’t think so.
Should we restore equity today? Yes.
The problem with reparations is that our ancestors have been, by definition, the biggest assholes of all. If they hadn’t, somebody else would have prevailed. We have billions of stories of injustice; nearly all of them have left no trace. So if we are to right the wrongs of our ancestors, we’re in for an infinite and unknowable list of reparations. It’s impossible to get them right or fair. We can not make people whole. We can’t do anything about long-dead people killing, suppressing, enslaving, or abusing other people a long time ago. What we can do is make the world fair now.
What we should do is correct the injustices of today. If one group within a society is systematically worse off than another, we should redress that. If one country has a track record of poor behavior, it should apologize—not to atone, but to convince other countries that the bad behavior will never happen again. If our foreparents enshrined some behavior that we now understand to be bad, let’s correct it now and stop our reverence.
Be Kind to the Past
But don’t be smug. Don’t judge the old ways too harshly. You will be judged the way you judge others who simply didn’t know any better. Right now, you are making some mistakes that you don’t even realize are bad, simply because as a society we haven’t evolved to that point of maturity yet.
What matters is not what happened. We can’t change it. What matters is what will happen from now on.
Spain bought slaves but didn’t capture or transport them from Africa, since the Treaty of Tordesillas with Portugal didn’t allow them to travel east of Brazil.
Interestingly, this is also the reason why African animals can’t be domesticated, whereas animals like sheep, dogs, cats, pigs or cows, which evolved separate from humans, didn’t evolve to fear them, and could be domesticated. This has a major consequence for human evolution: without domesticable animals, Africans had a harder time developing their economies, which was a handicap in the race for development.







Great article Tomas, as usual.
Great article, Tomas, it's impossible to speak the truth and spew positivity (as is typically prescribed, in the West at least).
1. Don't be "smug" or "judging of old ways" rightfully addresses our self-perceptions, but doesn't help us overcome DOMESTIC PROPAGANDA, especially in the West (since 2014). Propaganda has always been here, but we're on the same anti-China/Russia pivot and only getting worse.
2. The word "Slave" etymologically is from "Slav" according to "The Cambridge Medieval History," Vol. II, 1913
"The oldest written history of the Slavs can be shortly summarised--myriads of slave hunts and the enthralment of entire peoples. The Slav was the most prized of human goods. With increased strength outside his marshy land of origin, hardened to the utmost against all privation, industrious, content with little, good-humoured, and cheerful, he filled the slave markets of Europe, Asia, and Africa. It must be remembered that for every Slavonic slave who reached his destination, at least ten succumbed to inhuman treatment during transport and to the heat of the climate"
https://www.etymonline.com/word/slave
So perhaps or certainly we should chill with the focus on Africa, no?! You certainly bent over backwards to show how terrible tribal genocide has been for TENS of THOUSANDS of years...
Just a "tangent" within my point of helping the masses LEAN AGAINST MODERN [WEST] PROPAGANDA instead of keeping with the anti-Russia/China NARRATIVES.
2. It could or perhaps should be argued that "domestication" is the most massive and egregious of genocides. Perhaps most vegetarians would say "duh!". How many millions of chickens, pigs, and cows have we matrixed into existence only to murder them en-masse. I'm not a vegetarian, but I totally agree and yeah, it's absolutely terrible how barbaric I am and still ok with it.
Perhaps we can also extend "domestication" to notice our labor systems, caste systems, and class struggles. The competition of employees, companies, executives, sales people for business, class, status. And men are merely soldiers certainly motivated by one primary drive:
"first you get the money, then you get the power... then you get the woman"
and the 'wonderful' thing is that this doesn't even have to be acknowledged by the beautiful side of humanity. It doesn't have to be in the awareness or personality, albeit it is always in that eye-roll, whether we like to remember it. or not.
it's just that toxic masculinity is that much easier to pronounce than toxic femininity. Raar! :)
Barbarians at the gates - the Amazon prime drive delivers.