Great article, Tomas, it's impossible to speak the truth and spew positivity (as is typically prescribed, in the West at least).
1. Don't be "smug" or "judging of old ways" rightfully addresses our self-perceptions, but doesn't help us overcome DOMESTIC PROPAGANDA, especially in the West (since 2014). Propaganda has always been here, but we're on the same anti-China/Russia pivot and only getting worse.
2. The word "Slave" etymologically is from "Slav" according to "The Cambridge Medieval History," Vol. II, 1913
"The oldest written history of the Slavs can be shortly summarised--myriads of slave hunts and the enthralment of entire peoples. The Slav was the most prized of human goods. With increased strength outside his marshy land of origin, hardened to the utmost against all privation, industrious, content with little, good-humoured, and cheerful, he filled the slave markets of Europe, Asia, and Africa. It must be remembered that for every Slavonic slave who reached his destination, at least ten succumbed to inhuman treatment during transport and to the heat of the climate"
So perhaps or certainly we should chill with the focus on Africa, no?! You certainly bent over backwards to show how terrible tribal genocide has been for TENS of THOUSANDS of years...
Just a "tangent" within my point of helping the masses LEAN AGAINST MODERN [WEST] PROPAGANDA instead of keeping with the anti-Russia/China NARRATIVES.
2. It could or perhaps should be argued that "domestication" is the most massive and egregious of genocides. Perhaps most vegetarians would say "duh!". How many millions of chickens, pigs, and cows have we matrixed into existence only to murder them en-masse. I'm not a vegetarian, but I totally agree and yeah, it's absolutely terrible how barbaric I am and still ok with it.
Perhaps we can also extend "domestication" to notice our labor systems, caste systems, and class struggles. The competition of employees, companies, executives, sales people for business, class, status. And men are merely soldiers certainly motivated by one primary drive:
"first you get the money, then you get the power... then you get the woman"
and the 'wonderful' thing is that this doesn't even have to be acknowledged by the beautiful side of humanity. It doesn't have to be in the awareness or personality, albeit it is always in that eye-roll, whether we like to remember it. or not.
it's just that toxic masculinity is that much easier to pronounce than toxic femininity. Raar! :)
Barbarians at the gates - the Amazon prime drive delivers.
Great point about "domestication". It is the largest and still on-going genocide and slavery of sentient beings that we increasingly realize is wrong. It's great that plant-based products from new start-ups like Beyond Meat and Impossible Foods are becoming more popular now. It's also been surprising to see plant-based food products getting more and more shelf space at supermarkets in just a few years.
Also, great point on how "domestication" was extended to other spheres. It's due to tendency to own and accumulate things & other beings sometimes beyond logical reasons. Limitless accumulation starts to resemble a type of an addiction or "control freakiness".
I have been trying to agree with you for a while because I kind of understood what you were getting at. This time you are completely right apart from one thing: it is only in modern times that the money comes before the power and the woman. Historically, the power comes first then the wealth and the reproductive rights. It is only the relative peace and the the rule of law within some nation states that allows the accumulation of wealth before power. Schrodinger's nuclear missiles have kept the nation states fairly stable for a bit too.
The motivation of the drive is getting the woman for most men, for some power in itself is a motivator, but only for few. Most of the time money power is very indirect. Males do need to "dominate" in whatever hierarchy or social game they find themselves in. Women reward that "power" and/or "signaling" through their overt selection of that male as a mate.
So I think the point is that men have been "domesticated" by women across the full spectrum of men.
One could/should argue that in less lawful societies, women are treated like property. I love to bring up India, both with respect to their absolutely shameful treatment of women and the caste legal/economic/cultural system.
And the most shameful PROPAGANDA gap in the West is the focus on China's human rights violations in comparison to India's, simply because China's the economic threat that the shitty obsolete West PR machine of the "Her" variety is trying to manufacture consent around.
I'd estimate the coverage of China HR issues vs India's are at a ratio of 99:1. But the degree of violation is greater in India than in China perhaps by a factor of 10:1. India's cultural practices, legal systems, and corruption are still in the STONE age. Perhaps that's why China became a threat to the unipolar world order of the US and not India, in the first place, cause both countries trounce US at STEM.
But if we leave that tangent and do go back to females also being "assholes" via domestication of men ("Barbarians at the gate Amazon drive delivers"). I'd argue that the prettier the woman the LESS society and men "pressure" her to develop any sort of CIVILITY let alone intellectually. Not really sure I even have to make this argument as it is the definition of "selectivity pressures". Again, I'll use a saying to make the rest of the point: "Power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts absolutely".
Many years from now, when we DO look back at ourselves, one of the most barbaric things (in hindsight) will be the DISCORD between content, tone, and body language of FEMALES in communication. The violence embedded in it. The Myth of Narcissus is about a BOY getting lost in his own reflection?! Hmm.
Probe this from a different angle. Imagine a peak euphoria moment in the markets - 1999 Dotcom, 2007 Housing, 2021 Crypto/Meme stocks. There's social dinner with family and friends. Some couple is "sharing" about buying a second (or 4th) home (house) or cars or sending their kids to a fancier school. AFTER the dinner in another couple the women is chewing her husband out for not being as successful as the other guy/friend/brother... JEALOUSY FUELS GREED. a married man already "acquired" his sexual partner. It's the "mother" that's still in the rat race.... and/or the "pretty girl" that still has to feel special status past her "prime".
We are very far as a society from understanding that most men are sheep and soldiers and ACCESSORIES to mass murder.
I bet we never get there. The caste system is quite global and much more deterministic than our DNA being "human". So what if in the US you can go from low to middle class... power is held way above the 75th percentile of income and wealth and that part of the "ladder" is as barbaric as its ever been no matter the country. We can all admire the pyramids, though.
I should probably write the usual comment when talking about bad behaviour, whether it is children or adults: it is more helpful to talk about asshole behaviour than labelling someone as an asshole. As people have pointed out already, almost everyone is capable of asshole behaviour, just as the vast majority of people are capable of caring and kindness. Humans are generally not all bad or all good, just shades of grey depending on circumstances.
Not sure why you wrote "Only very recently have we started caring about others". Buddha lived 2500 years ago & Jesus over 2000 years ago. Yes, there have been many terrible things happening in different parts of the world after that. But, not everything everywhere has been horrible in these last 2-3 thousand years. Plenty of actions of love & compassion have been happening also which increased trust & co-operation otherwise, we would not have survived.
The problem is balance. I am trying at present to explain a concept I call 10/80/10 or simply the Bell curve of human personality traits. Humans are not all assholes, nor are they all compassionate and caring. For evolutionary reasons these personality traits are distributed along a spectrum within humanity and also can both exist within the same human.
When there are times of conflict, aggression and "assholeness" can be required for survival. But humanity also gains strength from co-operation, compassion and social cohesion. Sometimes I think the balance between the two is upset. Nature will reset the balance one way or the other, but if we understand the problem we can help correct it without some of the suffering that otherwise results.
Fascinating perspective. Thanks for this essay; wish I could share it! I have very little free time so don't always get to all your articles nor ever comment on the few I do read, but even reading only maybe 1 out of 10 has been worth being a subscriber! 💜
So grateful to have stumbled across you due to your Covid articles. Thanks for being here on Substack!👍
Cool Tomas. For sure, plenty of carnage in the past.
But if we're alive it's also because of the love of our ancestors. It took a lot more love and self-sacrifice for parents to keep their offspring alive in the past. Often meant going hungry so the kids could eat, risking your life to find food for them, working 16 hours days for the family. And the pain of giving birth... I think raising kids today is hard, can't imagine what it was two centuries ago.
So I would say, the great majority of people in the past were not assholes. Most just worked their asses off for their descendance, honestly, without violence. In fact, most of us probably wouldn't be alive today, were it not for a long chain of incredibly brave, generous, selfless and loving ancestors.
History books, like the news, give disproportionate importance to the crimes of a minority. But most of what has come down from the past is love, actually. That's what our ancestors transmitted to the future, by and large.
I agree with you. It makes me think a couple of things.
1. I think this is an opinion widely shared. It's not very polemic. But I might be wrong—I'm frequently wrong about what most ppl think!
2. Everybody has different aspects that define them. Everybody is good and bad. I wanted to emphasize in this article that ppl have been quite bad in a specific aspect that, when drawn as a pattern, makes specific decisions easier.
See my comment above(?) about 10/80/10. I would strongly assert that the majority of people are not assholes. The problem is that our leadership contests select for the most psychopathic, power-hungry personalities amongst us. So people like this have had a vastly disproportionate impact on our history relative to their frequency in the overall population.
If you know any good school teachers, ask them how they manage the "naughty" kids in their class. Teachers know that if they don't manage the difficult 10% preventatively well, the slightly less naughty 10% will be drawn into similar behaviour, then the next 10%....pretty soon you have an unmanageable situation. Western society let its "greedy kids" take over and run the show and now we are paying the price.
It's not good to "normalize" evil behavior by highlighting bad chapters of human history although I agree that human history has been ugly. It's little bit like saying animals rape, humans have always raped so rape is not such a bad thing even now. Same with lying, cheating etc. Also, comparing with other animals that hunt their prey is very unfair. Animal predators have no concept of greed or boundless accumulation. They hunt only to the limit of their stomachs. Also, not all animals are predators. And although animals also have feelings of love etc for others they don't have our level of understanding of ethics, morality, long chain of impacts of our actions (e.g. why wearing masks, getting vaccinated protects other vulnerable people) etc. So, you have to *expect more* from humans than animals. Humans don't need to be limitless predators in modern times as they can survive on gathering resources or agriculture or hunting to the limits of stomachs.
Someone with your kind of influence should be appealing to "better angels of our nature" like the famous book by Pinker. Yes, humans have both good & evil in them. When Hitler was unleashing immense suffering on millions, the same time Mahatma Gandhi was spreading the message of non-violence even in the face of violent oppression.
Human history wasn't just about conquests, violence & slavery. It also involved messages from Hinduism and Buddhism of compassion, mercy towards not just humans but all animals. There have been similar messages of love from Christianity too.
All of this is said in the post I think. I don't think there's any intention of normalizing it. On the contrary : the chapter on 2222 makes it clear that we are still violent today in ways that won't be acceptable in the near future.
(actually I'd even say most of the societal conflicts we have, especially between reactionaries and progressives, are around the amount of violence we accept to inflict on other beings)
I'd just like to point out that animals don't only kill out of hunger, and not only predators kill.
I've seen first hand a leopard kill a jackal just because she had the chance. On the off chance this particular jackal would one day kill her offspring (at least that's the explanation we have for this behavior).
This same leopard have recently been killed this year by 2 lions, because it eliminates competition.
I've seen buffalos attack two isolated teen lions, just because one day they could try and eat them (and soon stop when their mother arrived :D)
Chimpanzees are known to wage literal war on other tribes, and several act of horrendous torture have been witnessed (including ripping parts off enemies while they were still alive).
Extreme violence is very common in nature, even beyond the prey/predator dynamic.
Doesn't mean we should do it, of course. I think acknowledging we're also animals with a long history of violence can actually help us not committing the same atrocities again. Actually I think we're in a very non-violent society today. Some behaviors would have gotten people killed just a couple centuries ago.
Zebras and some antelopes can be domesticated. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K0LLJyWU_44 It takes some effort, though. Horses, otoh, were so hard to domesticate that all horses today have 1 grand-dad, the first and only wild stud early humans could get hold of (while over time many mares got caught and 'tamed').
Took the early horse-tamers a long while to mount those original-horses (probably they had to breed a tamer version from those they had caught). See all those bronze-age armies using: only chariots, not riders? Are tamer Zebras breedable? Again, it takes some effort first. We shall see. Untameable foxes got tamed: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Domesticated_silver_fox
There was a key mutation around scythia, about 4-6k years ago, that allowed domestication. Them another one that changed their backs and allowed to ride them. Both of these around the same time.
But horses had not co-evolves with humans, so they weren’t as genetically determined to be scared of us. Antelopes and zebras have, because we evolved in Africa. This is why there are extremely few animals domesticated in sub Saharan Africa (and why there are still big mammals there, as they were scared of us, unlike others elsewhere like mammoths
that key mutation ... cause or effect ... Any signs of change in sheep/goats/cattle/pigs/apples/corn/wheat/camel-DNA at around the time of their domestication? (c'mon, there must be!) . That zebra did not look very scared, did it? Nor did being scared helped any big mammal against those bunch of homo sapiens that interbred with Neanderthals - and invented the spear-thrower/atlatl 20k years ago. I assume saving Africa's megafauna was mostly low human population density in Africa due to too many murderous virus/bacteria/parasites. (yes and it might be HBD, too. no shame in a more energy-efficient brain) Contrasting humans' impact on megafauna with/without technology: https://westhunt.wordpress.com/2021/10/12/footprints-in-the-sands-of-time/ quote: "Amerindians had atlatls and could apparently kill any animal, no matter how large. Ecologically dominant. In fact, they seem to have driven almost all of the megafauna in North and South America into extinction over a fairly short period of time.
This [hypothetical] earlier population may not have had atlatls simply because they hadn’t been invented yet"
To predict or influence the future we need to understand the present and create an accurate model of reality. To understand the present we need to understand the past. We also need to learn what lessons we can, but also to be able to let go of the past so that we can more forwards. I am finally nearly done with problem list and all the related issues, but this article will very helpful as it links in with the main themes.
Great article Tomas, as usual.
Great article, Tomas, it's impossible to speak the truth and spew positivity (as is typically prescribed, in the West at least).
1. Don't be "smug" or "judging of old ways" rightfully addresses our self-perceptions, but doesn't help us overcome DOMESTIC PROPAGANDA, especially in the West (since 2014). Propaganda has always been here, but we're on the same anti-China/Russia pivot and only getting worse.
2. The word "Slave" etymologically is from "Slav" according to "The Cambridge Medieval History," Vol. II, 1913
"The oldest written history of the Slavs can be shortly summarised--myriads of slave hunts and the enthralment of entire peoples. The Slav was the most prized of human goods. With increased strength outside his marshy land of origin, hardened to the utmost against all privation, industrious, content with little, good-humoured, and cheerful, he filled the slave markets of Europe, Asia, and Africa. It must be remembered that for every Slavonic slave who reached his destination, at least ten succumbed to inhuman treatment during transport and to the heat of the climate"
https://www.etymonline.com/word/slave
So perhaps or certainly we should chill with the focus on Africa, no?! You certainly bent over backwards to show how terrible tribal genocide has been for TENS of THOUSANDS of years...
Just a "tangent" within my point of helping the masses LEAN AGAINST MODERN [WEST] PROPAGANDA instead of keeping with the anti-Russia/China NARRATIVES.
2. It could or perhaps should be argued that "domestication" is the most massive and egregious of genocides. Perhaps most vegetarians would say "duh!". How many millions of chickens, pigs, and cows have we matrixed into existence only to murder them en-masse. I'm not a vegetarian, but I totally agree and yeah, it's absolutely terrible how barbaric I am and still ok with it.
Perhaps we can also extend "domestication" to notice our labor systems, caste systems, and class struggles. The competition of employees, companies, executives, sales people for business, class, status. And men are merely soldiers certainly motivated by one primary drive:
"first you get the money, then you get the power... then you get the woman"
and the 'wonderful' thing is that this doesn't even have to be acknowledged by the beautiful side of humanity. It doesn't have to be in the awareness or personality, albeit it is always in that eye-roll, whether we like to remember it. or not.
it's just that toxic masculinity is that much easier to pronounce than toxic femininity. Raar! :)
Barbarians at the gates - the Amazon prime drive delivers.
Great point about "domestication". It is the largest and still on-going genocide and slavery of sentient beings that we increasingly realize is wrong. It's great that plant-based products from new start-ups like Beyond Meat and Impossible Foods are becoming more popular now. It's also been surprising to see plant-based food products getting more and more shelf space at supermarkets in just a few years.
Also, great point on how "domestication" was extended to other spheres. It's due to tendency to own and accumulate things & other beings sometimes beyond logical reasons. Limitless accumulation starts to resemble a type of an addiction or "control freakiness".
I have been trying to agree with you for a while because I kind of understood what you were getting at. This time you are completely right apart from one thing: it is only in modern times that the money comes before the power and the woman. Historically, the power comes first then the wealth and the reproductive rights. It is only the relative peace and the the rule of law within some nation states that allows the accumulation of wealth before power. Schrodinger's nuclear missiles have kept the nation states fairly stable for a bit too.
The motivation of the drive is getting the woman for most men, for some power in itself is a motivator, but only for few. Most of the time money power is very indirect. Males do need to "dominate" in whatever hierarchy or social game they find themselves in. Women reward that "power" and/or "signaling" through their overt selection of that male as a mate.
So I think the point is that men have been "domesticated" by women across the full spectrum of men.
One could/should argue that in less lawful societies, women are treated like property. I love to bring up India, both with respect to their absolutely shameful treatment of women and the caste legal/economic/cultural system.
And the most shameful PROPAGANDA gap in the West is the focus on China's human rights violations in comparison to India's, simply because China's the economic threat that the shitty obsolete West PR machine of the "Her" variety is trying to manufacture consent around.
I'd estimate the coverage of China HR issues vs India's are at a ratio of 99:1. But the degree of violation is greater in India than in China perhaps by a factor of 10:1. India's cultural practices, legal systems, and corruption are still in the STONE age. Perhaps that's why China became a threat to the unipolar world order of the US and not India, in the first place, cause both countries trounce US at STEM.
But if we leave that tangent and do go back to females also being "assholes" via domestication of men ("Barbarians at the gate Amazon drive delivers"). I'd argue that the prettier the woman the LESS society and men "pressure" her to develop any sort of CIVILITY let alone intellectually. Not really sure I even have to make this argument as it is the definition of "selectivity pressures". Again, I'll use a saying to make the rest of the point: "Power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts absolutely".
Many years from now, when we DO look back at ourselves, one of the most barbaric things (in hindsight) will be the DISCORD between content, tone, and body language of FEMALES in communication. The violence embedded in it. The Myth of Narcissus is about a BOY getting lost in his own reflection?! Hmm.
Probe this from a different angle. Imagine a peak euphoria moment in the markets - 1999 Dotcom, 2007 Housing, 2021 Crypto/Meme stocks. There's social dinner with family and friends. Some couple is "sharing" about buying a second (or 4th) home (house) or cars or sending their kids to a fancier school. AFTER the dinner in another couple the women is chewing her husband out for not being as successful as the other guy/friend/brother... JEALOUSY FUELS GREED. a married man already "acquired" his sexual partner. It's the "mother" that's still in the rat race.... and/or the "pretty girl" that still has to feel special status past her "prime".
We are very far as a society from understanding that most men are sheep and soldiers and ACCESSORIES to mass murder.
I bet we never get there. The caste system is quite global and much more deterministic than our DNA being "human". So what if in the US you can go from low to middle class... power is held way above the 75th percentile of income and wealth and that part of the "ladder" is as barbaric as its ever been no matter the country. We can all admire the pyramids, though.
I should probably write the usual comment when talking about bad behaviour, whether it is children or adults: it is more helpful to talk about asshole behaviour than labelling someone as an asshole. As people have pointed out already, almost everyone is capable of asshole behaviour, just as the vast majority of people are capable of caring and kindness. Humans are generally not all bad or all good, just shades of grey depending on circumstances.
Not sure why you wrote "Only very recently have we started caring about others". Buddha lived 2500 years ago & Jesus over 2000 years ago. Yes, there have been many terrible things happening in different parts of the world after that. But, not everything everywhere has been horrible in these last 2-3 thousand years. Plenty of actions of love & compassion have been happening also which increased trust & co-operation otherwise, we would not have survived.
If only Christians and Buddhists had largely abided by the teachings of their prophets...
The problem is balance. I am trying at present to explain a concept I call 10/80/10 or simply the Bell curve of human personality traits. Humans are not all assholes, nor are they all compassionate and caring. For evolutionary reasons these personality traits are distributed along a spectrum within humanity and also can both exist within the same human.
When there are times of conflict, aggression and "assholeness" can be required for survival. But humanity also gains strength from co-operation, compassion and social cohesion. Sometimes I think the balance between the two is upset. Nature will reset the balance one way or the other, but if we understand the problem we can help correct it without some of the suffering that otherwise results.
Fascinating perspective. Thanks for this essay; wish I could share it! I have very little free time so don't always get to all your articles nor ever comment on the few I do read, but even reading only maybe 1 out of 10 has been worth being a subscriber! 💜
So grateful to have stumbled across you due to your Covid articles. Thanks for being here on Substack!👍
That's super nice, Janice. Thank you, I'm super glad to hear!
At the beginning I didn't know where you were going besides "we're a horrible species", but good ending :)
Is the title a reference to Turtles all the way down ? No connection to this topic, but amazing book by John Green !
Yes and yes! You nailed it :)
Exactly what I was trying. I glad it landed!
I don't know if you've read Looking for Alaska, but if you haven't, you'll love it. What a punch in the gut.
Tell me more
Ah ! Difficult to do it without spoiling the book. I'll just say that the book is built in a way that makes the story all the more emotional.
I can't tell much more without risking to spoil it.
Found this one. Relevant:
https://twitter.com/arya_amsha/status/1610561469359480832?s=46&t=2JV92DuM-coOHASN7Ny11w
Cool Tomas. For sure, plenty of carnage in the past.
But if we're alive it's also because of the love of our ancestors. It took a lot more love and self-sacrifice for parents to keep their offspring alive in the past. Often meant going hungry so the kids could eat, risking your life to find food for them, working 16 hours days for the family. And the pain of giving birth... I think raising kids today is hard, can't imagine what it was two centuries ago.
So I would say, the great majority of people in the past were not assholes. Most just worked their asses off for their descendance, honestly, without violence. In fact, most of us probably wouldn't be alive today, were it not for a long chain of incredibly brave, generous, selfless and loving ancestors.
History books, like the news, give disproportionate importance to the crimes of a minority. But most of what has come down from the past is love, actually. That's what our ancestors transmitted to the future, by and large.
I agree with you. It makes me think a couple of things.
1. I think this is an opinion widely shared. It's not very polemic. But I might be wrong—I'm frequently wrong about what most ppl think!
2. Everybody has different aspects that define them. Everybody is good and bad. I wanted to emphasize in this article that ppl have been quite bad in a specific aspect that, when drawn as a pattern, makes specific decisions easier.
Hope that helps!
See my comment above(?) about 10/80/10. I would strongly assert that the majority of people are not assholes. The problem is that our leadership contests select for the most psychopathic, power-hungry personalities amongst us. So people like this have had a vastly disproportionate impact on our history relative to their frequency in the overall population.
If you know any good school teachers, ask them how they manage the "naughty" kids in their class. Teachers know that if they don't manage the difficult 10% preventatively well, the slightly less naughty 10% will be drawn into similar behaviour, then the next 10%....pretty soon you have an unmanageable situation. Western society let its "greedy kids" take over and run the show and now we are paying the price.
It's not good to "normalize" evil behavior by highlighting bad chapters of human history although I agree that human history has been ugly. It's little bit like saying animals rape, humans have always raped so rape is not such a bad thing even now. Same with lying, cheating etc. Also, comparing with other animals that hunt their prey is very unfair. Animal predators have no concept of greed or boundless accumulation. They hunt only to the limit of their stomachs. Also, not all animals are predators. And although animals also have feelings of love etc for others they don't have our level of understanding of ethics, morality, long chain of impacts of our actions (e.g. why wearing masks, getting vaccinated protects other vulnerable people) etc. So, you have to *expect more* from humans than animals. Humans don't need to be limitless predators in modern times as they can survive on gathering resources or agriculture or hunting to the limits of stomachs.
Someone with your kind of influence should be appealing to "better angels of our nature" like the famous book by Pinker. Yes, humans have both good & evil in them. When Hitler was unleashing immense suffering on millions, the same time Mahatma Gandhi was spreading the message of non-violence even in the face of violent oppression.
Human history wasn't just about conquests, violence & slavery. It also involved messages from Hinduism and Buddhism of compassion, mercy towards not just humans but all animals. There have been similar messages of love from Christianity too.
All of this is said in the post I think. I don't think there's any intention of normalizing it. On the contrary : the chapter on 2222 makes it clear that we are still violent today in ways that won't be acceptable in the near future.
(actually I'd even say most of the societal conflicts we have, especially between reactionaries and progressives, are around the amount of violence we accept to inflict on other beings)
I'd just like to point out that animals don't only kill out of hunger, and not only predators kill.
I've seen first hand a leopard kill a jackal just because she had the chance. On the off chance this particular jackal would one day kill her offspring (at least that's the explanation we have for this behavior).
This same leopard have recently been killed this year by 2 lions, because it eliminates competition.
I've seen buffalos attack two isolated teen lions, just because one day they could try and eat them (and soon stop when their mother arrived :D)
Chimpanzees are known to wage literal war on other tribes, and several act of horrendous torture have been witnessed (including ripping parts off enemies while they were still alive).
Extreme violence is very common in nature, even beyond the prey/predator dynamic.
Doesn't mean we should do it, of course. I think acknowledging we're also animals with a long history of violence can actually help us not committing the same atrocities again. Actually I think we're in a very non-violent society today. Some behaviors would have gotten people killed just a couple centuries ago.
Thank you, this sums up what I was going to say!
Zebras and some antelopes can be domesticated. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K0LLJyWU_44 It takes some effort, though. Horses, otoh, were so hard to domesticate that all horses today have 1 grand-dad, the first and only wild stud early humans could get hold of (while over time many mares got caught and 'tamed').
I want to see her ride it!
Took the early horse-tamers a long while to mount those original-horses (probably they had to breed a tamer version from those they had caught). See all those bronze-age armies using: only chariots, not riders? Are tamer Zebras breedable? Again, it takes some effort first. We shall see. Untameable foxes got tamed: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Domesticated_silver_fox
For antelopes, see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/antelope?variant=zh-cn#Domestication
There was a key mutation around scythia, about 4-6k years ago, that allowed domestication. Them another one that changed their backs and allowed to ride them. Both of these around the same time.
But horses had not co-evolves with humans, so they weren’t as genetically determined to be scared of us. Antelopes and zebras have, because we evolved in Africa. This is why there are extremely few animals domesticated in sub Saharan Africa (and why there are still big mammals there, as they were scared of us, unlike others elsewhere like mammoths
that key mutation ... cause or effect ... Any signs of change in sheep/goats/cattle/pigs/apples/corn/wheat/camel-DNA at around the time of their domestication? (c'mon, there must be!) . That zebra did not look very scared, did it? Nor did being scared helped any big mammal against those bunch of homo sapiens that interbred with Neanderthals - and invented the spear-thrower/atlatl 20k years ago. I assume saving Africa's megafauna was mostly low human population density in Africa due to too many murderous virus/bacteria/parasites. (yes and it might be HBD, too. no shame in a more energy-efficient brain) Contrasting humans' impact on megafauna with/without technology: https://westhunt.wordpress.com/2021/10/12/footprints-in-the-sands-of-time/ quote: "Amerindians had atlatls and could apparently kill any animal, no matter how large. Ecologically dominant. In fact, they seem to have driven almost all of the megafauna in North and South America into extinction over a fairly short period of time.
This [hypothetical] earlier population may not have had atlatls simply because they hadn’t been invented yet"
Yes.
Yes=fingerclick= 99% agreement
To predict or influence the future we need to understand the present and create an accurate model of reality. To understand the present we need to understand the past. We also need to learn what lessons we can, but also to be able to let go of the past so that we can more forwards. I am finally nearly done with problem list and all the related issues, but this article will very helpful as it links in with the main themes.