Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Philipp's avatar

I think this interview shows again one of the main problems of the EU:

The missing vision about how should this project should look like in the next decades.

Discussions about the future of the EU seem to only take place within Bruessels disconnected from national politics.

Asking friends living in smaller member states the impression seems to be that the purpose of the project is just integrating into German economy and everything else is just a show to hide this intention.

The economic integration is going well , I don't see that as a negative point. But taking this away what would be left ?

The Ukraine war is now showing that western security politics is situated at NATO and the "EU engine" France and Germany is not willing or able to provide leadership.

Regarding common culture and a feeling of living in a common sphere:

All arguments regarding this also apply to GB and the US maybe even to the whole anglosphere.

As a German the USA seems much closer than Portugal and honestly Australia is closer than Romania.

To set up the EU as a cultural project the question has to be answered:

What distinguishs the EU from the "Western World" ?

How are we special, what do we have in common what we don't have with other western countries?

I think the answer to those questions would also provide a vision how to proceed into the future.

Expand full comment
VictoriaF's avatar

Thank you, Tomas.

I was in Brussels in 2019 and took a tour of the European Parliament. I have not been outside the U.S. since then due to the pandemic, and so I take the EU issues particularly closely. I understand the challenges of democratic governing of a large number of diverse countries and realize that there are no perfect solutions. Nevertheless, two ideas come to my mind:

1. When deciding on the voting rules such as unanimity, 2/3 majority, and simple majority -- another option is rank voting. Rank voting makes people believe that their votes are not wasted and they are more likely to vote.

2. Europe would benefit of a unified energy policy. For example, if German's economy gets a disproportional hit from shutting off gas supply from Russia, other EU countries would share their gas with Germany.

Is idea-2 impossible? It's definitely very difficult. On related topic, German's resistance to nuclear energy is irrational, because a nuclear disaster at a French or Czech power plant would affect Germany similarly to Chernobyl's fumes covering Western Europe.

Please continue working with decision makers and raising critical issues,

Victoria

Expand full comment
13 more comments...

No posts