64 Comments
User's avatar
Daniel Suckfüll's avatar

Incredible story. I've heard and seen this before, but never in this level of detail. What was done to the Poles over the centuries is something that no people should ever experience. I wish them well in their goal of fortifying their country against future aggression from the east and hope that their allies to the west stay true to our shared values.

rmduenas's avatar

Just want to add that James A. Michener painted a very detailed portrait of all of Poland's tribulations along the centuries in his novel, Poland, first published in 1983. A wonderful read.

Paweł's avatar

You can also notice the territory around Białystok (north-eastern part), than in 19th century was direct part of Russian Empire, not Congress Poland. Białystok was kind of Russian Hong-Kong - the gateway between Poland and Russia where all trade was going (esp. textiles) and a lot of Polish companies created outpost to avoid duties. And it's also still visible on some maps.

Rafa Font's avatar

Getting the (great) Zanclean megaflood video in the middle of the (great) article about Poland is unfair to each content! They rob each other attention

Tomas Pueyo's avatar

You know I was struggling with that. I was excited to share it! And I don’t want to spam y’all!

GoodGovernanceMatters's avatar

Attaching the word spam to your work… The mere idea is absurd.

Tomas Pueyo's avatar

That's kind!

I feel like I shouldn't be sending more than 2 articles a week though. Am I being too conservative?

rmduenas's avatar

Hi Tomás, I have a folder just for your articles. If I do not have time to read them when you send them, I eventually find a way of making time for them. So, I would say that yes, you are being conservative.

Alexandra Brinkeborn's avatar

I voted on Professional storytelling because to me it's less buzzy-wordy than "business storytelling". I understand the power of keeping it very short but I played around with longer (probably too long) versions.

How to tell your professional story - A course on conveying your ideas and thinking in business

Also - will the course be full-time or when do you plan the lectures to take place? Asking since I am employed full time and need to plan accordingly :)

Tomas Pueyo's avatar

Interesting ideas. Yes, I probably need a longer title. It's a good idea.

The course will be online, a cohort-based course. There will be 3 lectures per week, probably around 9am PST / 12pm EST / 5pm GMT / 6pm CET. I will also organize project reviews and office hours around those times.

What else can I tell you?

Juan Enrique's avatar

Tomas, keep in mind that this time the opposition to the PIS didn't participate as only one coalition. So the map of the results is actually quite similar to the last one if you just plot the % that the more conservative parties received. The divide in Poland is quite similar to the one in Germany, nad it'll take at least some generations more to smoth the divide.

Tomas Pueyo's avatar

That's true, good point!

Juan Enrique's avatar

Just in case you don´t know, this year are the european elections, so we´ll get a new update on the political map soon

Quentin Wilson's avatar

I was about to suggest, "How to Tell Stories and Influence People", but Daniel beat me to it...

Miguel García Álvarez's avatar

The first time I came across this persistent border was in an article on Strange Maps almost 15 years ago ( https://bigthink.com/strange-maps/348-an-imperial-palimpsest-on-polands-electoral-map/ ). I did some digging at the time and got impressed with the differences, but I didn't get as far as you got in this article.

Amazing work!

Tomas Pueyo's avatar

What other maps have caught your attention that you haven’t seen in my articles?

Miguel García Álvarez's avatar

I'm probably the definition of a map-nerd, so most likely too many to count (I have 10,000+ maps stored in my OneDrive, which I'm trying to slowly curate and upload into an online catalogue - https://mapasmilhaud.com ).

I haven't read all your articles in detail, but I believe you have not covered yet the geopolitics of China: Increase their presence in Africa, control of high-tech minerals, new trade routes… That could be an interesting one.

Some maps to talk about this:

Chinese investment in Africa: https://www.businessinsider.com/map-chinese-investments-in-africa-2012-8

New Silk Road: https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2016/06/why-china-is-building-a-new-silk-road/

Chinese control over High-tech minerals: https://www.voanews.com/a/east-asia-pacific_voa-news-china_studies-reveal-chinas-dominant-position-high-tech-minerals/6206341.html

Chinese tourisim: https://elordenmundial.com/mapas-y-graficos/donde-viajan-turistas-chinos/

Tomas Pueyo's avatar

Beautiful maps!!

And interesting points about China. I will look into them. Thx!

Daniel Williams's avatar

”Business Storytelling” seems most accurate but also most dry. Your posts have great titles like this one! I found the title intriguing. Dale Carnegie had a good book title with “how to Win friends and influence people” which kind of sounds like what you’re aiming at. I can’t think of a better title, but just wanted to let you know that I believe that you can find one!

Martin Gerard's avatar

Wow, just wow. What a story, so captivating! Thanks!

Tony's avatar

The videos are amazing!!

Sia's avatar

This was a great read🔥Thanks Tomas! 🌟

Tomas Pueyo's avatar

You’re welcome!

Chris Robbins's avatar

What happened when millions of people were moved out of one area and into another? Did the people move voluntarily, or were they forced to (and how was that done)? Did they have to buy the homes from the former owners, who had gone to another country, or did they just walk into them? Was there any compensation provided to those who were displaced? The logistics are hard to fathom.

Tomas Pueyo's avatar

The Germans just had to leave, so AFAIK no buying. Remember: This was the Red Army steamrolling over the very hated Nazis, so no nicety there.

A lot of the land was nationalized though. Remember, this was a Communist country.

I believe Poles weren't forced to move, since many stayed in what's now Belarus. There are 300k-1.1M Poles there today.

But I am not 100% sure

This Wikipedia page discusses this event:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flight_and_expulsion_of_Germans_(1944%E2%80%931950)

Jakub Anderwald's avatar

What I heard from people living in Szczecin (AKA them or their families relocated there after WW2):

You came with a train with your belongings. You were either forcefully loaded onto the train (especially in the eastern parts of Poland), or happily jumped on it looking for a better life. Or any life at all, if you lived in the cities destroyed during WW2. The train arrived to a major city, let's say Szczecin. You jumped out and ran to a nearest house that looked empty. You went in, had a look around, if t was nice, you just claimed it. Usually you put something on the door marking it as claimed. If you were successful, the house became your property later on.

The further west you went into the city, the better houses there were and lower chance on them being claimed by other Poles. However, it also increased a risk of meeting German partisans, who were fighting the invading Poles. So if you grabbed a house, you could be shot during the night. But if you survived long enough for other Poles to settle in and the German guerilla to be kicked out, you ended up owning a nice house in a proper district.

I didn't do much research into how it really looked. I recall similar scenes as above depicted in Polish movies about that time period.

Tomas Pueyo's avatar

Oh wow that’s crazy. Can I add this to the quarterly update?

Jakub Anderwald's avatar

Sure thing. But please do some historical cross-checking for this, I only heard it as a story from some families I got to know while living there.

AKCH Haine's avatar

Nice one, what a history the Poles have seen and endured .

Tomas Pueyo's avatar

Hahaha I see you edited your comment. I assume you found the Ukraine article!

https://unchartedterritories.tomaspueyo.com/p/why-isnt-ukraine-a-global-superpower

AKCH Haine's avatar

Indeed. I found 2 articles on Ukraine :) Thanks .

Steve Mudge's avatar

Fantastic article, amazing info, thanks!

Zanclean Flood video was fantastic too.

törzsmókus's avatar

ewangelickiej doesn't mean evangelical (esp. not in modern American sense), it means Lutheran

Tomas Pueyo's avatar

Hahaha it's the one I decided not to translate with Google Translate... Translating from Polish is a nightmare! I assumed I could wing this one. WRONG! You can never assume with Polish.

Thanks for noting it!

Karol Jastrzębski's avatar

I could help with the translation next time. (If there will be a next time).)

Tomas Pueyo's avatar

It’s pretty ad hoc and I’ve finished the 2nd Polish article but I might need it. Thx!

törzsmókus's avatar

Didn't the Germans (in the 2nd..5th century AD) come from East?

Tomas Pueyo's avatar

All the depictions I’ve seen show them come from Denmark and southern Sweden. A lot of the knowledge about that comes from Roman records matched to archaeological finds.

But then of course where did these people come from before that?

The latest genetic data suggests 2-3 waves of people coming from the East as you say and wiping out the locals.